I gave this a three... I love your other work, but this tile seems way too simplistic and drags down the overall quality of tiles in it's neighborhood. I recognize that you got a lot of flat color to work with all around, but somehow I wish you did something more interesting with what you got.

Also, the lines just don't look as sharp as the other tiles on the quilt. overall it has some "jpegginess" to it.

I have to disagree with the simplicity factor. I think it could be even less complex and make it better. I do agree on the jaggedness, though. Could do with smoother edges.