please take your time with yout tiles. this one is very blurry and has a black line at the bottom.

I like this one a lot. Maybe by the color coherence I think. 5 from me. Anyway, I agree ireenqueen about the blurryness. But well, it has inspired me with your upper border, so, it is ok :)

not bad if you draw half of the object
on one of the border
and the neighbourg have to guess and continu what you did
( a clock)

good tile and good feedback.
I agree with most of the above... you do have a tendency to center objects in your tiles... next time try making that element larger, and letting 1/3 of it go off two sides. and yeah... really try to watch the black edges. those seams will really bring your score down, because they're really hard to blend with. Overall, a really nice piece.

Everyone has made some good points. Just wanted to say I enjoyed working with your border. cool tile.