But you should try to merge all the borders next time, would look better :)

Victorsan, I like this tile -- you took an obviously round element and turned it into the curving part of an ocean reef. I also like the cartoony shading on those air bubbles. I had the pleasure (and difficulty!) of doing the tile below this one, and .. well, you'll see what it looks like soon enough :)

Now, on that note, was the tile above you the one with that darker line, or did you do that? It looks like you could have maybe brought it around a little bit more, sacrificed some space to blend it through some. The suggestion of a perspective shift (from top of water to underwater) could still be preserved in this way.

Nice work!

My tile looks better now because of your wonderful artwork !
Continue like that, I just love it!

Thanks for your comments dudes. The darker line on the up side of the tile... I always try to blend all i can with the next tiles... i try to do my best... sometimes that´s impossible because of those dark lines. I dont want to say "hey, the dude of the upper tile made that stupid dark line", because i just cant remember...

Just be careful when you start the tile, check that the black box that you cut (i do this that way) is 128x128...

Thanks again for your comments, i feel proud of my work... i could never wonder that it would be so popular!