So well, again, a photocollage, right?
Most of your tiles looks like a copy&paste. ... hmm, it looks well if you dont lok in the details, but those copy-pasted parts are to obviously in my eyes.
This tile is from Mainquilters 19: The Warm, Magnificent Light
Tile Info
Comment:
By: bannerimage
Checked out at: January 10, 2003
Checked in at: January 10, 2003
Checkout tile:
In Context
![](https://s3.amazonaws.com/static.ice.org/quilts/quilt_135/current/18373.png?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAJPNRWEFB3VFDG6FQ&Expires=1732468422&Signature=mNCKxHigmT8vFdPf0mt3%2FJ%2FC5Aw%3D "Perhaps no "warm" light, but magnificent ;) (PS: black line in the border from the bottom-tile) by Duracel")
Posts
.
Re: .
I dont care if it is copy pasted or whatever...In tiling its the IDEA that u come up with that blends in perfect & i think thats more important than the artistery of it ;)
Re: Re: .
I see both sides. As a picture this tile rocks. If its not a manip then it deservs a 5 and or a coin. If its manip then its still a good picture, but less points for not making the picture from scratch. A good tile is one that you really are not sure if it was maniped or not. I can not tell %100 on this one, so I give it a 5!
Good job
Good job
Re: Re: Re: .
Well, I do use photo manip in some of my tiles. I do not think there is anything wrong with it...I do however feel that tiles that are painted from scratch deserve a higher score (unless it's a photo manipulation quilt that is) In my tiles i just try to concentrate on the edges and do something interesting while i am at it.