I'd say the tile is fine. It blends well, especially for an artist's second tile. WiZ, I think you should think twice before making a negative comment like that :(

i agree that the tile is fine, i like it. but the blending isn't perfect, which is part of the tile game.

there is an obvious line at the bottom where this tile meets the edges it was given. and an obvious single pixel line of lightened pixels that this tile sends on to the next guy to try and deal with.

i suggest zooming in on the tile and checking the edges carefully before uploading.

i would also suggest voting positively once in awhile. vote for tiles you like, and not against artists that you don't .
i see 3 votes and an average of -1.6... your peers may pick up on this and reward you accordingly.

I gave him some leeway because it's his second tile. The right border has some light lines, sure, but at least it's not along the whole side. With those, if it wasn't a tile on the edge of the quilt, someone could have blended shapes into them. On my latest visible tile, the one with a name about the table, I would have never thought to make it a tabletop if not for the probably accidental dark smudge on the bottom right of the tile to the left.

Where i said that this tile is bad? The tile is ok. I just said that this "man" can make tiles better than before.